SortSwift vs BinderPOS
An honest comparison for TCG store owners evaluating their options. BinderPOS closed to new signups in February 2025.
About BinderPOS
BinderPOS launched in 2018 as a Shopify-based POS and inventory system for TCG stores. TCGplayer acquired it in July 2022. On February 19, 2025, TCGplayer announced they would stop accepting new BinderPOS customers, directing stores to explore other options. Existing customers can continue using the platform. Pricing is $100/mo (Binder) or $150/mo (Binder Pro), plus commissions.
About SortSwift
SortSwift is an independent, all-in-one TCG ecosystem: inventory, POS, scanning, autopricing, marketplace sync, buylist, and proprietary hardware. No Shopify requirement, 0% commission on POS and marketplace sales. Free tier with 2,500 items and 500 scans/month. Paid plans from $19/mo to $499/mo. Founder-led support through Discord.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | BinderPOS | SortSwift |
|---|---|---|
| Architecture | Requires Shopify subscription | Independent platform, Shopify optional |
| Commission on POS sales | 2% website commission | 0% commission |
| Commission on TCGplayer | 2.5% TCGplayer commission | 0% commission on synced sales |
| TCG games supported | ~17-18 TCGs (catalog) | 26+ TCGs for scanning and catalog |
| Card scanning | TCGplayer mobile app (~3 games) | 99.9% accuracy, 26+ games, ~2 sec |
| Scanning entry points | TCGplayer app + CSV + manual | 5 entry points + CSV import |
| Sorting hardware | None | Super Sorter + Simple Sifter |
| Buylist | Yes | Yes |
| Point of Sale | Yes | Yes, unlimited terminals |
| Events | Basic event management | Pairings and brackets (beta, Core+) |
| eBay sync | Yes | Yes |
| CardTrader sync | No | Yes |
| ManaPool sync | No | Yes |
| Square sync | No | Yes |
| Misprint sync (Pokemon) | No | Yes |
| TCGplayer integration | Native (owned by TCGplayer) | Semi-sync (order deductions only) |
| New signups | Closed (Feb 19, 2025) | Open |
Where BinderPOS Wins
Native TCGplayer integration
Owned by TCGplayer, so the connection is first-party with full listing and pricing sync.
Longer track record
Operating since 2018, more established in the TCG POS space.
Shopify theme ecosystem
Built on Shopify, so stores get access to the full Shopify theme marketplace.
Where SortSwift Wins
0% commission on POS and marketplaces
Flat subscription pricing. No percentage taken from your sales.
Independent architecture
No Shopify dependency. SortSwift runs as a standalone platform.
26+ TCGs with dedicated scanning
5 scanning entry points: mobile app, web scanner, file upload, Simple Sifter, and Super Sorter.
Proprietary sorting hardware
Super Sorter and Simple Sifter for automated card intake and sorting.
More marketplace sync targets
Shopify, eBay, CardTrader, ManaPool, Square, and Misprint (Pokemon).
Modern UI and founder-led support
Active Discord community with direct access to the development team.
What Will You Actually Pay?
Drag the sliders to estimate your monthly cost on each platform. The calculator uses the BinderPOS Binder tier ($100/mo) for comparison.
Monthly Cost Calculator
Compare your estimated monthly costs. BinderPOS uses the Binder tier ($100/mo). Both include standard 3% payment processing.
Total monthly sales: $10,000
Website sales (% of total): 30%
TCGplayer sales (% of total): 20%
BinderPOS (Binder tier)
Subscription: $100/mo
Shopify: $39/mo
Processing (3%): $300
Web commission (2%): $60
TCGplayer commission (2.5%): $50
$549/mo
SortSwift (Core tier)
Subscription: $249/mo
Shopify: not required
Processing (3%): $300
Commission: $0
$549/mo
At this sales volume, BinderPOS may cost less in subscription and commissions. SortSwift may still save time through scanning, hardware, and additional marketplace sync.
What Store Owners Say
“Switched from BinderPOS after TCGplayer announced the shutdown. SortSwift had us running in 3 days. The scanning alone is worth it.”
LGS Owner, Florida
“The commission savings paid for the entire SortSwift subscription in the first month. We do enough volume on our website that 0% commission matters.”
Store Manager, Texas
“Being able to scan 26 games instead of 3 changed our buylist workflow completely. We take in collections in half the time now.”
LGS Owner, California
Ready to migrate?
Our step-by-step migration guide covers exporting from BinderPOS, importing into SortSwift, and running both systems in parallel until you are confident.
Frequently asked questions
Is BinderPOS still accepting new customers?
No. BinderPOS stopped accepting new customers on February 19, 2025 after TCGplayer announced the wind-down of their POS products. Existing customers can continue using BinderPOS, but no new signups are available.
Does SortSwift charge commissions on sales?
SortSwift charges 0% commission on POS transactions and on all synced marketplace sales. You pay a flat subscription and standard payment processing fees from your processor.
Can I keep my Shopify store if I switch to SortSwift?
Yes. SortSwift integrates with Shopify for inventory sync, order routing, and pricing. You can continue using your existing Shopify store and theme.
How does TCGplayer integration differ between the two?
BinderPOS is owned by TCGplayer, so its integration is native. SortSwift offers semi-sync with TCGplayer: order deductions are automatic, but listing creation and pricing pushes are not supported through the TCGplayer API.
What TCG games does SortSwift support for scanning?
SortSwift supports 26+ TCG games for card recognition including Magic: The Gathering, Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Lorcana, Flesh and Blood, One Piece, and many more. BinderPOS relies on the TCGplayer mobile app which supports roughly 3 games for scanning.
Does SortSwift have a free tier?
Yes. SortSwift offers a free Entry tier with 2,500 inventory items, 500 scans/month, and core features. Paid plans start at $19/month.
What hardware does SortSwift support that BinderPOS does not?
SortSwift offers the Super Sorter (automated belt-fed card sorting machine) and the Simple Sifter (single-card desktop scanner). BinderPOS does not offer proprietary scanning or sorting hardware.
How long does migration take?
Most stores complete migration in about a week: 1 day for export and import, then 3-7 days of parallel running to verify everything. See our detailed migration guide for step-by-step instructions.
Learn more
Switch from BinderPOS with confidence
Free tier with 2,500 items. No commission on any sales channel. Start today.